John McDonnell: Labour List: 16-11-16
Andy Burnham’s arrival as PM was very welcome. As were his promises of doing things differently. But his honeymoon might be over if he blows this opportunity to make real change.
Within Labour, there was a collective sigh of relief after Keir Starmer departed the scene. We were going so much against the grain of what Labour historically stood for that we couldn’t go on the way we were.
In our guts we knew cutting benefits to the disabled, leaving children and young people in poverty and ignoring the heartrending atrocities taking place in Gaza were not what any Labour government should be associated with.
That’s why Andy Burnham’s election as leader was welcomed across the party’s political spectrum. The initial period of office with its inspiring conference speech and its litany of small cost of living policy announcements alongside opening the door to the potentially truly transformative social care project has bought the party the time to move on from Starmer.
The budget was also as much a breathing space budget for the new administration as for the general population.
But now the honeymoon is coming to a close.
Key decisions are coming thick and fast, which will increasingly determine not whether we are ending neoliberalism as he called for in September but whether we are even moving on from being a lightweight, more presentable version of Starmer and Reeves.
My message to Andy is: just don’t blow this huge opportunity of a Labour government with a massive majority and the overwhelmingly supportive goodwill of the Parliamentary Labour Party, our party members and supporters and so many of our people.
Milburn report
We await Milburne’s full report on how we address the NEETs question but any reneging on the commitment that the reform of the system would not be on the basis of crude cuts in benefits, will lead us back into dangerous political territory.
A basic test for the Milburne proposals is whether they will make young people poorer. There is universal backing for supporting young people back into work but impoverishing them in the short term, when the support and the jobs they need do not yet exist, will be seen as performative cruelty, playing to the malign prejudices that this is a snowflake and malingering generation.
Setting up support and advice services and creating the training and job opportunities for young people will take time. The PCS staff survey, published last week, of DWP staff, who will be administering any new system, shows the challenge facing the government. 77 percent reported there being not enough staff to administer existing programmes, explaining why 73 percent report a backlog of cases and 76 percent experience stress.
Cutting young people’s benefits before the support is available to help get them into work, and when economic growth has still to create the job opportunities they need, will prove not only to be self-defeating but will place more pressure on an already disillusioned and scapegoated generation. If the upfront start-up costs of the new system need to be raised, how about not cutting benefits but a Gordon Brown like windfall tax on the £60 billion bank profits expected this year?
Green issues
On environmental issues, the decision on Jackdaw has been tolerated but following on from the accusations about the watering down of commitments on heat pumps and EVs, agreements to Rosebank and similarly to a 3rd runway at Heathrow will see the party’s green credentials irreparably shot and questions will be asked about what brilliant strategist thought giving Zak Polanski a boost when the Green Party’s balloon is deflating would be a political masterstroke.
Gaza
On Gaza, the ongoing barbarity of the IDF and the heartbreaking suffering of the Palestinians has created a growing sense of frustration at the failure of the government to turn Ed Miliband’s conference speech, admitting the government had got it wrong on Gaza, into effective action. At the same time the 4000 plus, many elderly, protestors, who are waiting to be brought before the courts and the young direct action protestors, classed as terrorists, serving long sentences, all testify to the mistake that proscription of Palestine Action was and the need to reset this legal stance. Instead of prosecuting our own people for seeking peace, shouldn’t our government be leading the charge to flood Gaza with aid and to indict the Netanyahu regime as war criminals.
With the arrival of Andy Burnham and his commitment to a broad church party, the culture of the party has definitely changed and ministerial doors have been opened for discussion and constructive engagement. But the decisions over the coming weeks will determine whether anyone was seriously listening.
The Labour leadership knows it has the votes to drive any policy through and there is no mood for Parliamentary rebellions on any scale. But it should also know that disillusionment eventually breeds corrosive dissent.